I wanted to finally take some time out to address some personal pet peeves. The situation is that you’ve just asked someone what they thought of a particular movie. Their response is terse and intellectually shallow. Don’t get me wrong…I’ve said some of these things at some point in my life. We all fall into these conversational ruts. But please take a minute to think about how pointless these responses to a film are (of course, these mindless responses are not necessarily relegated only to film). So, here are the Top Ten Dumbest Movie Reviews:
10. It didn’t live up to the hype. So what? Screw hype. You have to be able to just take a movie on its own terms. This culture is so obsessed with knowing as much as they can about a movie before seeing it to get their excitement up. So they watch clips, trailers, behind the scenes interviews, etc to tweak their enthusiasm levels or just out of curiosity. But all of these things - especially trailers - are designed to make something look better than it is. You have to understand that. So, if you really want to experience a film as it is intended to be viewed, you have to go in with a clear mind.
9. The book was better. See my blog entry about this topic.
8. It wasn’t bad/terrible. Huh? This is the kind of response you hear from people who a) Don’t really care for movies anyway; b) Didn’t care to see that particular movie to begin with; c) Are very very cynical people overall. Either way, never trust this “review” from anyone’s lips.
7. It was different/strange. So what? Were you hoping it was going to be a formulaic? Was it strange because it didn’t end with an explosion thus fueling your Cro Magnon urges? Ending a conversation with “Ehh…it was different” is about as exciting as answering a question about your job with “Oh…been keeping busy. Pass the Cheez Whiz.”
6. It was interesting. This is closely related to 7. You have to support your searing insight somehow. How was it interesting? Were you moved by an actor’s performance? Did the plot resonate with you? Or was it just interesting because you somehow managed to struggle and stay awake through most of it?
5. It was entertaining. Hmmm. Well movies are supposed to be entertaining, but they should do more than that. If you’re only goal is to be entertained, then go sit in your bathtub with the shower running and pretend you’re in a sinking submarine. It’s much cheaper and doesn’t require clothes.
4. I hated it because I don’t like [insert actor or actress name]. This can be a tough one. We all have certain actors that just make our skin crawl or that we just don’t like for reasons we aren’t sure of. That’s natural. But, if you look beyond this bias, I think you’ll be surprised at some truly great movies you’re overlooking. I used to hate Richard Gere. Maybe it was because I didn’t agree with his politics. But one day many years ago, I decided to give him a shot. As a result, I ended up really liking Primal Fear, Chicago, and The Hoax (to name a few). If you are a true lover of film, you have to be able to separate the artist from the art. If you can’t do it, then you probably shouldn’t watch movies.
3. I wouldn’t see it again. OK. This falls under the category of More Info Needed. Is that because you don’t see movies twice or because you didn’t like it? Eh never mind. I won’t ask for your opinion again.
2. It was too depressing/scary/sad/cheerful. Well, film is supposed to elicit an emotional response. And it won’t always be happiness. Life isn’t like that either. If you only want to watch movies with happy endings, you are severely limiting your experience and approaching film with blinders on. Sometimes, evil will get away (Anton Chigurh in No Country for Old Men) but you have to look at what the film is saying overall. On the other hand, I don’t have a lot of respect for cynical people who disown a movie for being too happy or joyous. Again, that may be the intent of the movie. Just remember that film is subjective. What is depressing to you may instead be poignant and moving to me. But don’t dismiss a film just because it’s emotional impact isn’t what you wanted. Find the truth in the art for yourself.
1. It’s not perfect. I have news for you. Most movies aren’t. I’ve even admitted that the Golden Gun rating on this site isn’t for what I necessarily consider to be “perfect” movies. A film can win an Oscar and still not be a perfect movie. I don’t go to movies to see a perfect film. I am going because I love the medium and because I want to have a great experience with it. A movie should move you in some way. You should have some kind of relationship with it, and some of those relationships can be intense. But they can still have some minor flaws. Stop saying something isn’t perfect. Just talk about your encounter with it was.
What other ones annoy you?
One of the biggest things that bothers me about Hollywood is the lack of originality in the product it continues to churn out. We are mercilessly pelted with sequels, remakes, and adaptations of comic books, TV shows, and SNL bits. Never is this more evident than during the summer months. Of course, I don’t just automatically discount all sequels and remakes. But, to actually look at what is forthcoming in the upcoming months is very disquieting.
I apologize for the delay. In late January, I was involved with a death in the family. After dealing with the grief and logistics of that, it’s just taken me some time to get going with this site again. But here we go.